« 5x5 Fasted 4/27/09Westin Hotel 5x5 Workout 4/11/09 »

10,000 Kettlebell Swings

I have finished the 30 day 10,000 35 lb. kettlebell swing challenge!

At long last (after a month), I have completed the challenged and done 10,000 35 lb. (one “pood") kettlebell swings in thirty days! Based on the records below, I spread these swings out over 24 days, averaging in at approximately 417 swings a day. Clearly, at the end things got a little lumpy thanks for some busy weekends and a weekend away (at a wedding in Cali).

I am glad to be done with this challenge. Kettlebell swings are an intense form of exercise, and at a minute and a half for 55 swings, that totals up to about four and a half hours of straight kettlebell swings spread out over a month. Sure, if you’re working out three times a week for 45 minutes, you’re putting in nearly 10 hours of workout time a month, but you also are taking brief rests in between sets at the gym, and kettlebell swinging is more intense than regular cardiovascular exercise. Alls I’m sayin’ is that 4.5 hours of kettlebell swings is intense!

And it’s also monotonous. This is why I wouldn’t do this challenge again. Swings just get boring, like work, and exercise should be fun and challenging, not just challenging. Other drawbacks to this challenge is that it puts your hamstrings in a generally achy state most all the time—not enough to be super annoying, but enough to be irritating. I think the high repetitions is also not so good for knees and lower back. Yes, if you’re swinging properly, you’re not blowing out your knees or your back, but when you’re doing such high reps, you start using stabilizing muscles and putting strain on joints that normally are left alone. One final negative is that interjecting so many swings throughout your day demotivated me to doing any additional weight-lifting. That’s a big “negative” to a program like this.

On the plus side, it seems that the daily, dispersed swinging time had some benefits as far as body recomposition. However, it’s at the margin (Read: it’s hard to tell). I wish I had done a before and after vertical leap, but I didn’t. All this swing work helped me really get a feel for the hip-snap action that makes a swing most powerful, so chalk up that for another benefit.

All said, though, I wouldn’t do it again. Did I mention I was glad it’s over?

Original Write-up and Records/Notes

The idea for this 30-day kettlebell swing challenge emerged from a combination of wanting to do 1,000 swings in one workout session (I did 500) and some twitter from @sandysommer (Charm City Kettlebells) about a 10k swing challenge. I seem to recall that challenge involving doing something like 200 swings a day.

Well, my 10K swing challenge is intended to be completed in 30 days. That means I have to do 333 swings per day, every day, for 30 days. I’m using my 35 lb. kettlebell, and the intention is for this not to replace other workouts. In other words, I’d like to additionally continue doing weight training and other exercise in concert with this challenge. Also, the total can be broken up however makes the most sense. Currently, I’m breaking it down into three rounds of two sets each. The rounds are spread throughout my day, which makes for a nice five minute break between working, blogging, etc. Default method is double-arm. “SA” is noted where alternating single-arm swings (Sets of 11 per arm, typically). “SAA” is noted where single-arm swings are performed with a flip/pass at thea peak of every swing. A set of 55 takes me a minute and a half (exactly) to complete.

I started the challenge on 3/16/09. Check back here to see my progress:

3/16: 333 (3x[56,55])
3/17: 333 (3x[56,55])
3/18: 333 (2x[56,55]SA, 1x111)
3/19: 333 ([56,55], 1x111, [56,55])
3/20: 333 ([56x3 w/1:30 rest between sets], [55x3 w/1:30 rest between sets])
3/21: 333 (9x33, 36)
3/23: 666 (3x[56,55], 9x33, 36)
3/24: 333 (3x[56,55]SA)
3/25: 333 (9x33SA, 36SA)
3/26: 333 (4x66SA, 69SA)
3/27: 333 (4x66SA, 69SA)
3/28: 333 (4x66SA, 69SA)
3/30: 333 (4x66SA, 69SA)
3/31: 666 (2x[9x33SA,36SA])
4/1: 333 (4x66SA, 69SA)
4/2: 333 (4x66SA, 69SA)
4/3: 333 (9x33SAA, 36SAA)
4/4: 333 (4x66SA, 69SA)
4/7: 666 (36SA, 9x66SA, 36SA)
4/8: 666 (36SA, 9x66SA, 36SA)
4/9: 666 (2x[9x33SA,36SA])
4/13: 333 (36, 9x33, 10)
4/14: 500 (10x50SA)
4/15: 499 (4x100SA, 99SA)

Total to date: 10,000

Notes: 3/21 - Starting to really nail the snap aspect of the swing. It feels very much like the GHD sit-up hip flexor snap feels, where you actually feel your heels want to slide back on the floor due to the snap action. The upswing motion is much more forceful when the snap is right. 3/27 - despite doing no other exercise other than the challenge this past week, I think this sort of dispersed, daily workout may be having some positive impacts on body composition. Of note, I am practicing LeanGains style IF, which is more or less having a compressed daily eating window (so fasting from say 10pm to 2-4pm everyday). 3/31 - over halfway through this challenge and I just found where I originally read about it at innergrrr.blogspot.com. Key difference to that challenge which is set at six weeks (42 days), I’m doing it in 30. Trivial difference? Surely not! 4/4 - Gotten into the “swing” of doing five sets @ of three left/three right single-arm 11 rep mini-sets of swings. I like this breakdown mostly because the 11-rep swap makes each “big” set feel much smaller, and considerably less boring. I do wonder if I could further compact it into 3 sets of 111. Hmm. 4/7 - I took a two day hiatus from the swing challenge to see if I couldn’t alleviate some lower back soreness. It didn’t quite do the trick though. What’s weird is that it doesn’t seem like muscle soreness and it doesn’t seem like any part of my swing aggravates the sore area. So I’m puzzled.

PermalinkPermalink Wednesday April 15 at 04:06:24 pm, by Justin — 9 comments »

9 comments

Comment from: Dan Linehan [Visitor]
Wow, nice job! I just started doing 35lb swings and I can't imagine doing that many in a month.

Did you notice increases in your overall fitness levels during the trial? Did your back pain go away?
07/30/09 @ 12:48
Comment from: Justin [Member] Email
Thanks Dan -

I would definitely not recommend anyone do this in such a short period of time as I think it just begs for an injury -- plus it gets very, very tedious doing that many swings day in and day out (And on catch up days ... just brutally boring).

The back pain has subsided at this point. I can't think of the last time I noticed it, though I'd estimate it went away about a month and a half ago -- something like that.

Once you master 35 lb. swings, you can bump to a higher kettlebell. Once you nail down 53 lb. swings, when you switch back to 35, it feels light. Kinda cool!
07/30/09 @ 12:51
Comment from: Sam [Visitor]
You need to learn how to do swings properly. Without that you would injure yourself and not to mention the mental strain leading to fatigue.

I would strongly advice you to get a PT with an RKC. I started out like you. I went all out swinging thinking how hard can it be. It's not a pushup or a curl it's a very complicated moment. Once I learned the proper movement I feel very flexible and lean even with a 50/day swings schedule.
11/14/09 @ 23:29
Comment from: Rob - @formerfatguy [Visitor]
your post title caught my attention because i too am considering taking on the 10,000 swing challenge. I've been looking for other people who've done any number of consistent 250, 500 or 1000 swings a day.

I have just started with the swings though. I'm currently in a 30 day 3000 swing challenge so that I can just get used to the swings and the consistency. Then I'll up the weight, and then the volume.
11/29/09 @ 22:21
Comment from: Justin [Member] Email
@Sam,

I respectfully have to disagree -- if anything, the 10K/30 day challenge honed my form down to a hip-snapping science. I'm about 99.9% sure my form wasn't the problem.

What felt like the problem was doing 300 to almost 700 swings/day for 30 days straight. You mention 50 swings/day -- that's not very many at all. I feel confident I could easily do 50 swings/day every day ad infinitum.
11/30/09 @ 18:27
Comment from: Lyndsay Killoran [Visitor] Email
I manged the 1000 kettlebell swings in a training sessions, I have done this 4 days in a row now, and I didn't find it too bad, I did 100 swings at a time and then broke it up with 25 sit ups in between then a further 100 swings and so forth till I had reched the 1000 swing mark. It took me about 40 mins to begin with but I have managed to get quicker and I didn't find it boring as it was a challenge and made me work out really hard.
03/16/10 @ 05:20
Comment from: Mike [Visitor]
Any well conditioned athlete should be able to do at least 500 a workout with a 35pound bell. But if your form is off you will have a hard time doing even 100 in one workout. The timing and snapping of the hips is the key. As justin mentioned - doing this many hones the hip snap to a point where you could use very little energy to complete 100 at a time.

When i first started the hips snap felt weird and used up a lot of energy. Now its a natural movement that i can do with no impact to my endurance.

I love these type of challenges. But if you want well rounded challenges. Use the WOD's on crossfit.com

03/30/10 @ 02:40
Comment from: Claire, Ireland [Visitor]
well done on your challenge..I am currently doing it and am on day 4...have 1,600 under my belt and am finding it pretty okay so far. I am using the 16kg (35lb ) bell and i am trying to improve my endurance for kettlebell sports competitions. I'm completing my swings in soft competition style as opposed to hard style. Its a great idea and I have to say I will be proud of myself having completed 10,000 swings in 30 days or less!! Plus Im going on holidays on day 31 so I will have additional 10,000 swings, along with my regular workouts which can only help my bikini body quest!!! keep up the challenges!!
05/15/10 @ 16:00
Comment from: Amy [Visitor]
I saw this challenge on facebook. I decided to try it. Being new to KBs by a few months I thought I knew what I was doing. Only been trained by video by Valrey and a few others. However those videos weren't enough to tell me that I could experience back pain.
So I gave up after a couple weeks with 6000 swings in. I have just done some research today about KB swings and lower back pain. I will be practicing implementing these
practices to eliminate the pain and hopefully come across another challenge again soon.
05/17/10 @ 14:38

Leave a comment


Your email address will not be revealed on this site.

Your URL will be displayed.
(Line breaks become <br />)
(Name, email & website)
(Allow users to contact you through a message form (your email will not be revealed.)

This sub-blog captures my daily workouts (if any). It was created in July and has been maintained fairly religiously since August 2008. Its purpose is to serve as a record of activity and a reminder to stay active. Theoretically, it will serve as a record of what "works." Questions or comments, just let know. Navigating it for specific workout ideas is best accomplished using the tag cloud.

Receive alerts on updates to blogs on this site through your preferred XML reader and Subscribe! Huh?
Have you benefited from my random musings and pontifications? If so, throw me some support via a donation!

JustinNO on Twitter . . .

Follow my tweets
 << < September 2010 > >>
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
      1 2 3 4
5 6 7 8 9 10 11
12 13 14 15 16 17 18
19 20 21 22 23 24 25
26 27 28 29 30    

Recent posts

Writings

Linked Down

Recent Books

User tools

Add to Technorati Favorites Clicky Web Analytics
blog engine